Chaos is the new normal

Share
Chaos is the new normal

Hello,

How has this crazy week been for y'all? US has midterm fever, half of Europe is on the streets, India has shown a bizarre side of 'democracy' that should baffle the staunchest of the central government's supporters.

I am usually very excited about elections, whatever they might be. State, municipal, even housing society elections. If I have a vote, I cast it. I have always considered it my duty to do so. I still do. But the past six months of following the SIR news, having done the SIR myself, and then the government's handling of people asking questions about electoral practices in India has me questioning some of it. It scares me that I am questioning the point of it all.

But then again, if we all think that way, how will we bring about any change? I have been thinking about it a lot and I think getting involved and engaged with local politics is the first step in the right direction. Even as doordesis, working within the communities we live in can be both rewarding and a way to claim some of that agency back from Big Brother, Big Tech, Big Everything.

Have you tried this already and if yes, do you mind sharing it with us? I would like to feature ways in which people in the DoorDesi community are engaging with their local communities.

Looking forward to it!


Just the gist

đź”— The logistical nightmare of saving a democracy

Two stories this week look separate and are actually one. Together they answer a question the state has apparently stopped bothering to hide: where exactly are you allowed to protest, and what happens if you ask?

First, the place. On October 11, the day after the mass detentions, the Delhi Police Commissioner signed an order de-notifying Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site. The replacements are Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and a ground in East Delhi. The order discloses no committee report, gives no reasons and cites no source of power. Delhi Police told the Delhi High Court it was acting on the Supreme Court’s October 9 order. The Solicitor General told the Supreme Court that order was not the basis and that a committee had reported. On October 15 the Court issued notice on a petition challenging the move and said it would examine whether anyone considered how the site is used and whether it works.

The usual debate is whether Jantar Mantar is irreplaceable. The Supreme Court has already held there is no right to protest at one particular place. The better question is what the state owes when it herds dissent into designated sites. If protesters must go where they are sent, the state must send them somewhere adequate. That means a site that can actually take the protest, a process that works on the day, and a venue within sight of the people the protest addresses. The order shows none of the three.

Now the people. Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka of the CJP were freed on October 21 after seven days in judicial custody under preventive proceedings. The Delhi High Court ruled in Aldanish Rein (2018) that this custody is capped at seven days, and that verifying sureties cannot justify keeping someone in. By the petition’s account, bank-verified sureties were on offer from the first week. Some were rejected on October 18 without the sworn inquiry the law requires, and similar ones were accepted on October 21. Former Delhi High Court judge S. Muralidhar, who wrote Aldanish Rein, said he doubted the magistrate was even prepared to acknowledge the ruling. The petition adds that the sequence ran backwards, with arrest first and the formal notice coming on October 14 while they were already inside. When the High Court took the matter up, Justice Prasad pointed the pair towards revision and they withdrew the petition, so the court never had to rule on any of this.

The terms of release include a written undertaking from Das and Ranka not to call for protests at Jantar Mantar while its de-notification stands. In other words, the site is gone by order, and the people who might have used it have been bound by bond not to ask for it back.

➡️ Worth keeping in mind that protests rarely die by ban in supposedly democratic spaces. They die by logistics: a venue that does not exist yet, a procedure to follow “separately”, a surety that keeps being unacceptable until the clock runs out. Most people hauled before these magistrates have no lawyer, no following and no High Court petition. In 2017-18, Delhi’s SEM courts sent 6,944 people to judicial custody, and many were too poor to furnish sureties. Das and Ranka were the privileged case, and they still did the full seven days. If you have family in Delhi who might attend a protest, the practical lesson is to know their rights before they go.

đź”— Delete fast, restore slow

We have spent weeks on what the Election Commission does with voter rolls. This is about the direction it seems to push them: out.

After the much contested Form 6 comes its cousin, Form 7 which is how someone objects to another person’s name on the roll. The Commission’s own manual says an objection must be published in a Form 10 listing for seven days, shared with parties and put on notice boards, before an Electoral Registration Officer can act. The person concerned also gets a personal notice and 15 days to reply. From August 31 to October 16, Delhi received 13,462 Form 7s, but only 9,199 appear publicly. That leaves 4,263 objections, nearly a third, with no known objector, target or reason. A senior election official told the Hindu that an unlisted objection is invalid and cannot be acted upon. The Delhi CEO’s office did not answer the paper’s questions.

Now Bengal. The Civic Research Group, an independent team of researchers and field contributors, collected appeal records one by one. Of 30 lakh voters whom judicial officers examined and restored to the roll, the Commission has appealed against 14.76 lakh, or 49.2%. These people have already passed two rounds of scrutiny. The Commission has not said on what grounds it is appealing, who decided to file, or whether each case was reviewed individually.

The geography is hard to miss:

  • Malda, Murshidabad and Uttar Dinajpur hold 44.6% of all appeals against inclusion.
  • In Muslim-majority seats, appeals equal 5.9% of the draft roll. In seats where minorities are under 10%, it is 0.6%.
  • The 80 seats TMC won in 2026 hold 52.6% of the appeals, though they have just over a quarter of the voters.
  • In 29 constituencies, appeals outnumber the 2026 winning margin. In Sujapur, 61,036 appeals sit against a TMC margin of 60,287.

In 83 constituencies the Commission is trying to remove more voters than the judges did. In Chanchal, judges found 4,170 of 73,901 ineligible and the Commission appealed against 34,958 of the rest. If every appeal succeeded, nearly 70% of everyone placed under adjudication would be off the roll.

None of this can be resolved quickly. Tribunals have decided only 5.4% of appeals, and in Malda it is 938 of 3,03,896. Since September 21 no tribunal has been able to upload an order, because judges refused to log into the Commission’s portal with Aadhaar credentials. Municipal elections are expected to be announced next month.

➡️ In August, Justice Bagchi said appeals against exclusion should come first, since losing a vote is a harm and challenges to inclusion have other remedies. Two months on, the queue runs the other way, the portal is jammed, and the objections feeding it include thousands that were never published. Each case is one person defending their place on the roll twice, with no explanation of why they are being scrutinised. If you have family in upcoming election states, ask them to check their name on the current roll and keep copies of everything they submit. This is a battle that we should intend to win. No vote is protected unless every legitimate vote is protected.

đź”— When businessmen run foreign policy

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, on his second India trip in six months, met Jaishankar and business leaders in Mumbai, then flew to Gujarat to tour Reliance’s twin refineries at Jamnagar, the world’s largest single-location refining complex. The US ambassador has described this trip as “a little more business-focused” than the May one. Washington has not published an agenda for the Jamnagar stop, and Reliance has not commented. So everything below is analysts reading tea leaves, though the leaves are unusually legible.

Let's start with why Jamnagar. The complex refines 68.2 million tonnes a year, of which 35.2 million is for export, which makes Reliance India’s biggest exporter of diesel and jet fuel and a “swing supplier” when other regions go dark. Right now West Asia and Russia are both disrupted. The US midterms are a few weeks away, and the Trump administration is under pressure over pump prices, diesel especially. It has even eased sanctions on Russian diesel exports, including to the US, to cool prices. There is no confirmed sign that Rubio is shopping for diesel, and refiners sell where margins and shipping costs favour them. Still, a Secretary of State touring a fuel exporter weeks before an election does not need much decoding.

Then there is Texas. In March, Trump announced a refinery at Brownsville, the first new US refinery in five decades, thanking Reliance for its “tremendous investment”. The headline figure is $300 billion, but that is not an investment. It is the estimated value of the crude going in ($125 billion over five years) plus the fuels coming out ($175 billion). Still, it gives Washington a foreign-investment trophy and Reliance a foothold in the world’s biggest oil-consuming economy. Also, in the latest episode of 'Trump changed his mind' he waived the 100% tariff on big buyers of Russian energy, India included after signing off on the tariff only last month. Interestingly, Reliance has been a major buyer of Russian crude. So... the writing is hiding in plain sight.

There is also an American and Venezuelan crude angle. Washington wants India to buy more US energy to rebalance trade, and the US is currently India’s fifth-largest crude supplier, behind Russia, Iraq, Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Reliance’s refineries are complex enough to handle heavy Venezuelan crude, and Reliance already buys a lot of it. The article notes that the US now effectively controls the marketing of Venezuelan oil, which would make Reliance a useful outlet.

And one more suspicious piece of the puzzle is Starlink. Days before the visit, Elon Musk asked on X whether Ambani is “the real boss of India”. Not by name but we all knew who he was talking about. Reliance replied that it welcomes competition, Starlink included, and that Jio’s own satellite service is also awaiting clearances. Musk answered “Much appreciated”. Coincidence? I think not.

➡️ Strip away the diplomacy and this trip is about three things: who sells oil to India, who buys fuel from India, and who gets to be in the room when that gets decided. And if one thing is clear, it is that the US is not even pretending to care whether the Indian government is in the room or not as long as the businessmen are. Not the best posture for the state but who cares when the businessmen present in the room are also the ones dropping big money as 'donations' into the bank accounts of the leading party.

đź”— The case of a meeting seemingly forgotten

Hardeep Singh Puri is India’s oil minister. This week he is also the man in a US Department of Justice photograph, sitting across a table from Jeffrey Epstein with nobody else visible in the frame. It comes from Dataset 9 of the Epstein files, released in January.

The problem is that Puri said in February that he met Epstein “three or maximum four” times over eight years, and only “as part of a delegation” of the International Peace Institute. His office now says he never claimed he had not met Epstein alone, that he cannot recall which meeting this was or whether others were present before or after, and that the photos show a “working meeting” in “professional attire”. It also says he never visited Epstein’s island, and that meeting Epstein a few times cannot support an inference of wrongdoing. That last point is fair, and nobody in this story has alleged misconduct by Puri. The question is the gap between “as part of a delegation” and a photograph with no delegation in it. Because what could they have discussed in his official capacity as a representative of the Indian state?

Then there are emails. They span June 2014 to June 2017 and record at least three meetings at Epstein’s Manhattan townhouse, in February 2015, January 2016 and May 2017, all booked through Epstein’s assistant. Epstein introduced Puri to LinkedIn co-founder Reid Hoffman, and Puri pitched him on India’s digital economy. Epstein also asked Puri to help get an Indian visa for his assistant, and Puri passed it on to be handled “on a priority basis”. In December 2014, Puri wrote asking Epstein to tell him when he was back from his “exotic island”, so he could visit and bring him books to “excite an interest in India”. Puri’s office says the emails show the contact was about investment.

What is interesting about all of this (the extremely problematic part of working with somoeone like Jeffrey Epstein aside) is the timing of this latest photo dump. The photo dump happened right around the time that Rubio was going to visit India for his very innocent meeting with an Indian billionaire. Also, India is in a trade deal negotiation with the US that has been in the 'almost done' stage for weeks now. So could the photo dump be a negotiation tactic being used by the US against India? Could it mean that the meeting was more than just about investment as Puri's office has been claiming. In any case, what does this say about India's foreign policy and its standing as a strong counter to the US and the Global North in geopolitics.

➡️ A handful of professional meetings with a controversial (to say the least) financier is not proof of anything but the minister’s own account has now been contradicted by his own photograph. If the government believes the meetings were routine diplomacy, the simple fix is to publish what was discussed.

đź”— Where there is no alcohol, there is hard drugs

Bihar went dry on April 5, 2016, and police have spent the decade proving they can enforce it. They have seized about 3.16 crore litres of liquor and made around 7.15 lakh arrests, which works out to roughly 8,650 litres and 196 arrests every single day. Already says a lot about how (and if) prohibition even works. But then there is another more problematic story brewing under this.

The National Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act cases in the first five months of 2026 came to 1,905, already more than all of 2022 and nearly three times the 697 in 2019. Ganja seizures nearly doubled between 2022 and 2025. Tablet seizures went from 29,762 in 2022 to 9.29 lakh in five months of this year. Injectable pharmaceuticals went from 3,677 in 2022 to over 3.8 lakh in the same five months. Heroin is climbing too, and the newest name on the list is “kota”, a raw heroin variant sold in tiny vials, which has already seen its price jump as seizures rose.

The people at the sharp end are the young. Only 11 juveniles were detained under the NDPS Act in the seven years from 2016 to 2023. In 2024 alone it was 50. Beneficiaries of Centre-supported de-addiction centres in Bihar rose from 1,487 in 2022-23 to 29,429 in 2024-25, almost twenty fold, yet those centres operate in less than a third of the state’s districts. A psychiatrist says patients used to arrive dependent on cannabis and other plant-based substances, and are now increasingly arriving with heroin dependence.

Police and doctors link the shift to prohibition through simple economics. A bottle of whisky that sells for around Rs 1,500 in Bihar’s black market costs several times what a small packet of adulterated brown sugar does, at Rs 300 to 500, and the high lasts longer. Covid then gave the market a push, when migrant workers came home from Punjab, Delhi-NCR and Mumbai carrying new habits and contacts. Some of the rise in seizures also reflects more enforcement and a newly built narcotics apparatus, and a merged prohibition and narcotics bureau from September 2025. Both things can be true.

➡️ Bihar has now run a ten-year experiment in banning one intoxicant, and the lesson is that demand moves to whatever is cheaper and easier to hide, and for a teenager with Rs 150 in his pocket, that is not a bottle.

đź”— Encryption so guessable that Big Tech pulled the plug

When you open a website that starts with HTTPS, your browser checks a digital certificate to decide whether the site is who it claims to be. Those certificates come from certification authorities, and browsers keep a list of the ones they trust. This week, Google, Mozilla, Apple and Microsoft all removed trust from a set of certificates tied to eMudhra, Bengaluru’s digital identity company, after a researcher found something strange about how its keys were made.

Eight intermediate certificates had private keys generated with too little randomness, which means an attacker could potentially reconstruct them in seconds. Six were meant for authenticating websites and two for signing software. In the wrong hands, that would allow someone to issue convincing fake certificates, impersonate a legitimate site, intercept supposedly encrypted traffic, or make malware look trustworthy. A researcher reported it to the browser companies on October 17. Google pushed an emergency Chrome update last week, Mozilla used its central revocation system, and neither required users to update or restart anything. Apple and Microsoft followed suit.

eMudhra’s stand is that the flaw dates back to a key-generation exercise on April 30, 2025. Something went wrong in that process and created a second, weak set of keys alongside the strong ones, and the weak ones were then published to browser trust stores. The company says its infrastructure was not compromised, there was no data breach, only one of the affected ones was ever used in production, and none issued certificates to end users. It also says its Indian digital signature and eSign businesses run on separate infrastructure and are unaffected.

Google said no website certificates chaining to the six affected certificates had shown up in public transparency logs before it blocked them, which limits how far a fake certificate could have travelled. India’s CERT-In issued its own advisory on October 21, telling website administrators to find certificates relying on these authorities, replace them, update trust stores and watch transparency logs. But neither CERT-In nor the browser companies have established whether the keys were ever actually used to steal anything.

eMudhra is India’s largest certifying authority in the digital signature market, with about 38% share by value according to its own investor presentation. That is the domestic business of signing documents and verifying identity, and it is a separate world from the global website-certificate system affected here. Indian certifying authorities are licensed by the Controller of Certifying Authorities, so the two should not be confused.

➡️ The unsettling part is how little the flaw depended on a clever attacker. It was a bad key-generation run, with no breach needed, at a company trusted by the world’s biggest browsers. The trust system worked in the end, because an independent researcher found it and four companies acted within days. But the whole model assumes that every authority on the list gets randomness right every time, and this is a reminder that one slip can ripple across the internet. So, keep browsers and phones updated, and never click through a certificate warning, however urgent the site claims to be.


That's all for today, folks! See you next week.